How to Plan for a Reluctant Reader

How to Plan for a Reluctant Reader: Putting the Puzzle Together | This Reading Mama

Teaching reluctant readers can be like putting together a puzzle that’s missing several pieces.  And, if we’re honest, sometimes teaching them is like putting together a puzzle that’s missing the overall picture.  There are so many factors that can make readers reluctant, making it hard to plan for them.  In this post, I hope to provide you with resources for some of those missing puzzle pieces.  I pray that these resources will be a blessing to you and your reluctant reader.

*This post contains affiliate links.  To read more about this, please see my disclosure policy.

1. Many Reluctant Readers Lack Interest and Motivation

?Motivation? Road Sign with dramatic clouds and sky.{photo credit}

Let’s just call it like it is.  Some reluctant readers hate reading.  As reluctant readers age, a by-product of struggling to read is a low reading esteem.  This directly impacts motivation; or lack of.  Sometimes, this is an “easy” fix.  Sometimes it is not.  Here are a few suggestions when planning for readers who lack the motivation to pick up that text and read:

  • A steady diet of reading on his/her reading level.  These are texts the child CAN read and comprehend without much assistance.  If you’re not sure how to pick those “just right” texts, you will find TONS of tips and practical help for doing so in my ebook How to Choose “Just Right” Books: Helping Kids Grow as Readers.
  • Find a younger reading buddy.  Older readers (who are reading on a lower level) may find those “baby” books more tolerable if they’re reading them to younger children.
  •  Readers (not just reluctant readers) like to read about subjects for which they are interestedEven if the texts are below or above their reading level, texts that interest them are a great option.  I love Melissa’s list in chapter 12 of Book Love and refer to it quite often.
  • Read non-fiction.  This is always a great place to start because the reluctant reader can pick texts on topics that interest him.
  • Readers need to be told what they are doing right.  Are they going back and correcting mistakes?  Are they able to answer “easy” questions about the text?  Is he using the pictures to help him figure out unknown words?  Praise your reluctant reader for the things he’s doing right.  I also love Amy’s list on things never to say to reader.
  • Re-work text when appropriate.  Sometimes reluctant will be more willing to read a “baby” book if the pictures are removed from the text.  To do this, type up the text onto a single sheet of paper and let them read.
  • Read poetry.  Shel Silverstein or Jack Prelutsky poetry was always a favorite of the struggling and reluctant readers that I tutored.  The short text, humor, and lower reading level made these ideal.
  • Read aloud to the child; even if the child is older.  Find texts that may be too hard for the child to read that are of high interest to her and read it together.  Sometimes, reluctant readers get stuck in the mindset that reading equals saying the words right and they forget that reading is all about enjoyment and understanding.  Reading aloud helps to make this part come alive.  (Listening to books on CD or an iPod/iPad would also work.)

 2. Many Reluctant Readers are Actually Struggling Readers

young boy reading{photo credit}

It may be that your reluctant reader is missing important puzzle pieces in one or more of these areas: letters and their sounds, phonological awareness, phonics, word identification (with sight words), fluency, & comprehension.  Any one of these missing skills can directly affect reading.  Here are a few online resources you can check out when planning for these puzzle pieces:

Letters and Their Sounds

Use the assessment tool on pages 40-41 of Cool Tools to help you figure out which letters/sounds your child does or does not know.  If you choose to make your own assessment, be sure that the letters are not in ABC order.

  • Start with learning the letters in their name
  • Visit Carisa or Erica for their Letter of the Week curriculum (I’ve used both and HIGHLY recommend them)
  • Jolanthe also has some alphabet printables here
  • Reading the Alphabet-a FREE reading curriculum to take young readers a little deeper into their ABC’s, book/print awareness, & phonological awareness
  • Sound Tubs- these are fun to make yourself and hands-on for learning letters and their sounds
  • See more alphabet goodies on my ABC Pinterest board

Phonological and Phonemic Awareness

What is phonological awareness? Simply put, it’s being able to recognize and manipulate the sounds in words.  Phonemic awareness is under the umbrella of phonological awareness and is being able to recognize and manipulate the individual sounds (or phonemes) within words. Children with a good understanding in phonological and phonemic awareness can recognize and create rhyming words, blend and separate syllables, isolate beginning and ending sounds on words, blend sounds together to make words, and separate sounds within words.

Word Identification and Fluency

Sight Words (also sometimes known as high frequency words) are a huge part of reading.  How much so?  The first 100 words alone on Fry’s list make up 50% of what you read!  Amazing.  It goes without saying that if kids can’t automatically recognize these important words, fluency (and comprehension) are compromised.  What are some ways you can plan sight word learning for your reader?

  • While there is a Dolch list of sight words, I prefer Fry’s first 100 words, listed in order of frequency and that’s the order I recommend.  Start with the first 5 and move on from there.
  • Sight Word Games, like this one, make learning fun.  Learning sight words through play is definitely NOT boring!  This post has an entire list of the sight words games we played this past summer.  I also have quite a few more sight word games on my sight word Pinterest board
  • Reading the Easy Way- Beth has developed a sight word program that she sells- she now has a Level 1 and Level 2.  If you’re interested, you can read my review of Level 1.
  • Sight Words You Can See- uses imagery, mnemonics, and humor to help learn those irregular words.
  • Start a Word Wall- this is where you store all of the sight words your child has learned thus far.  ALuv (in 1st grade) has 5 sight words a week that we focus upon.  After the week is over, I place them on his word wall and hold him accountable for reading and spelling them correctly.
  • Consider your child’s word development.  Are you expecting too much?  Sometimes sight words don’t “stick” because your child is not developmentally ready.
  • Technology- our three favorite apps for working on sight words are Word BINGO Magnetic ABC (my 1st grader spells his words on here) & Teach Me 1st Grade.  Samson’s Classroom is another computer program that we use about once to twice a week.
  • Sight word identification and fluency are kissing cousins.  If your child struggles with fluency, try some of the activities in this post.  Find reading passages that lend themselves to reading with expression (characters talking, poetry, etc.) and try echo reading.

Phonics

While recognizing words by sight is important, this is not the only strategy that readers need to learn.  Reading by analogy (using known words and word chunks to help them read unknown words) is also an important skill and one that proficient readers still use.  If you’ve followed my blog for very long, you’ve probably noticed that my absolute favorite way to teach phonics is through Word Study: a developmental study of the patterns within words.  When planning out your phonics program, here are some tools for your box:

 

Comprehension

Sometimes, reluctant readers don’t have any issues with recognizing words automatically or reading by analogy.  These readers can actually read texts well beyond their years.  But ask them a question about what they just read and you’ll get a blank stare or the infamous, “I don’t remember” answer.  Here are some things to consider when planning for them:

  • What are some comprehension strategies?  Click here to read about them.
  • Explicitly model and teach comprehension strategies- I love the way Amy of Teach Mama posts about this in her learning through read aloud series.
  • Starting January 7th, Carolyn of The Wise Owl Factory will be doing a 5 day series on Reading Comprehension.  I am super excited to read and learn from her.  You may also want to check out other bloggers tackling literacy that week.
  • Sometimes, students don’t understand the text structure of fiction or nonfiction; which affects their ability to weed out important from not-so-important pieces of the text.  Text features within nonfiction may also need to be taught, as these features aid in comprehension.
  • Again, reading aloud to your child helps your child see that reading isn’t just about “barking” the words; its about enjoyment
  • I also have a Pinterest board for comprehension strategies.  You may find more resources there, including some great anchor charts for comprehension.

3. Some Reluctant Readers Have Deeper Issues that Affect their Reading

Homework Series{photo credit}

If reading has become something both you and your child want to avoid at all costs, there may be more going on…something deeper. Some kids have a shorter attention span, which can cause stress when asked to sit for long periods of time to read.  Sometimes, there are processing issues like dyslexiaIf you’ve “tried everything” and you (and your child) are still frustrated, then check out these resources:

  • Start by documenting what you observe.  Does she struggle with phonics?  Is he frequently reversing letters, even in the 5th grade?  Is she frequently unable to answer those questions that require her to read between the lines?
  • Take your documented observations to someone knowledgeable about reading disorders (your child’s pediatrician may have a referral for someone in your area).  A local school may also have some great referrals.
  • If you think your child may have dyslexia, read more about it here or you can take an online test for dyslexia
  • To read more about red flags, check out Melissa’s post: When to Worry About Your Child’s Reading
  • For more information on struggling learners in general, check out Jennifer’s post: Planning Homeschool for the Struggling Learner

 

Books I Recommend for Reluctant and Struggling Readers

In my book, How to Choose “Just Right” Books: Helping Kids Grow as Readers, I have practical tips and advice for knowing what a “just right” text is for your child. This is important for ANY kind of reader, but especially reluctant and struggling readers. It can be purchased for $3.99.

HowtoChooseJustRight-325

Reluctant & Struggling Readers

Phonics & Sight Words

Comprehension

Older Readers

Additional Blog Posts and Sites for Reading Help

 Want to read more homeschooling “How To” posts?  Click here or on the image above.

 

Follow along so you don’t miss a thing:

~Becky

 

Comments

  1. Really helpful-I need to go over the resources slowly. Having learned to read quickly and easily using “look and say”, it has come as a bit of a shock to have a child who has found learning to read slow and difficult. Probably doesn’t help that I’ve had to learn phonics properly for the first time!

  2. This is a really helpful post for all parents. Thanks for putting it together. We’d love for you to share it in our After School Link Up this week. We use our Love Books approach with our children from very early on and it’s had such a great affect on our children. http://www.theeducatorsspinonit.blogspot.com/2012/12/intro-to-abcs-of-after-school.html

  3. Excellent post Becky! Lots of great resources. I’m sharing with my readers. :)

  4. Lots of great resources here. I look at learning to read like putting a puzzle together too. There are many thought processes working together in a competent reader. Figuring out what an early reader needs to learn early is very important I think. Struggling readers have a difficult time changing their thinking patterns while reading as they get older. If a reader is not using all the necessary thought processes, they practice reading in a way that makes it harder for them to incorporate the missing pieces as they get older.

    I hope some parents and teachers are able to figure out missing pieces and use some of your resources to catch a few struggling readers early. The work you put into this post will benefit others. Nice work. I’m sharing this post in a few places today. Happy New Year to you and yours!

  5. Danielle O'Brien says:

    Wow, so much great information!! Thank you so much!

  6. This is wonderful! i am sharing it with my student teachers who are completing reading practicums, and my colleagues who teach reading methods!! :) (and on my blog as well!)

  7. thanks for mentioning Book Love and Imagination Soup!!

  8. I have a reluctant reader who is older than my younger reader, the younger child is advanced and reads books to the older child. Can this help the older child at all?

    • I’m sure there are many benefits of the younger sibling reading to the oldest. I would offer just three words of caution: 1- be very careful that you or the youngest child is not making any negative comments about your youngest child being able to read better than your oldest and 2- make sure that your youngest isn’t doing the work for the oldest. When your oldest is “stuck” or unable to read something, do not let your younger child jump in save the day. Reluctant readers often have the strategies in their heads, but the motivation to pull up those strategies is in neutral. :) 3- Make sure you give them time each day to read separately so that the reluctant reader is reading books of her choice and level. Hope that helps. Great question.

  9. Becky, it’s like all in one encyclopaedia for struggling readers! What a wonderful post – I am glad you pulled it out of your archives. I am going to be pinning and sharing it.

  10. What a terrific article – thoughtful and full of useful resources. A very generous and interesting post – thank you!

Trackbacks

  1. [...] friend Becky at This Reading Mama did a planning post for reluctant readers. Please visit her site for some great [...]

  2. […] How to Plan for a Reluctant ReaderStruggling Reader Series:  10 Things Struggling Readers NeedTeaching Spelling through Word StudySight Words When They Just Don’t Stick […]

Leave a Reply