• Welcome
  • Blog
  • Shop
  • Learning Apps
  • Alphabet
  • Learn to Read
  • Phonics
  • Spelling
  • Struggling Readers
  • Comprehension
  • Writing with Kids
  • Free Printables

This Reading Mama

Phonics or Sight Words? Teaching Kids to Read

By thisreadingmama 16 Comments

So which is it? Phonics or sight words? This is how some approach the art of teaching reading. It’s got to be one OR the other. But if you’ve read my blog for very long, you already know my answer. And you also know that I’m setting you up by asking the question with an or in the middle of it. 🙂

Phonics or Sight Words - Teaching Kids to Read - This Reading Mama

Undoubtedly, my answer to the question is BOTH, with a high dose of naturally immersing and integrating it into your day, such reading (everything) together, pointing out letters, words, and phonics patterns, singing, playing with sounds in words, watching educational shows, playing educational games; multiple and meaningful exposure is what I like call it.

Why Phonics?

The English language is based on the alphabetic principal. Letters make sounds, certain combinations of letters make sounds, etc. And these letter patterns/combinations are more reliable than you think if you study them closely. Word study is a great way to help kids understand the logic (or “rules”, if you’d like) of these patterns. The goal of any spelling or phonics program should be to help kids “crack the code” and apply the “codes”  in other words as they read and spell. Programs that focus on learning words by sight only unfortunately ignore the “code” of our language; that our language is indeed alphabetic.

Phonics begins with making letter-sound associations. Without this basic knowledge of letters and their corresponding sounds, learning words would be quite a futile task for most, if not all, children. In my post, Sight Words: When they Just Don’t “Stick”, I talk more about how kids develop through word learning and when the best time is to introduce the idea of sight words to kids. Sight Words: When They Just Don't Stick ~ understanding the development of word learning | This Reading Mama

Why Sight Words?

There are some words that appear with enough frequency in a child’s “diet” of reading and writing that we want her to know them by sight. We call these sight words. Instead of stopping each time to figure out the word using decoding skills (sounding it out or finding word patterns, such as ow), we want the word to become automatic; to be read within one second of seeing it. This DOES NOT mean, however, that phonics cannot come into play, too. It most certainly helps a young reader to understand that she can sound out did; that she can apply her phonics knowledge to the word and read it. But note also that there are some sight words young readers cannot figure out through phonics alone (the, was, and of are just a few).

Two common lists of sight words are Dolch’s word list and Fry’s word lists. Both lists include words that are most commonly found in independent readers for kids, starting in early Kindergarten. Personally, I like Fry’s list better (it’s more comprehensive), but NOTE THIS: ANY word came be a sight word for a child if she knows it by sight, even her name. If a child knows the word by sight, it is a sight word for that child. Sight words typically become automatic when a child has had multiple and meaningful exposure to the word (it goes back to integrating and immersing your kids into words everyday through reading, writing, playing, etc.)

Why BOTH Sight Words and Phonics?

If you’re a math person, allow me to venture here for a moment. When we first teach young children their math facts (4+4=8 and such), we start by pulling out the manipulatives, showing them in concrete ways how 4 of this plus 4 of that equals 8. We want children to understand how the math fact works (the nuts and bolts, if you please). We want them to have the ability to solve different problems by showing us HOW they did it.

But as young children become older children, we want them to move past using, or even needing, those manipulatives to solve 4+4=8. We want their basic math facts to become locked in their memory. Automatic. While they could still show us HOW they got their answer, it isn’t so necessary anymore. As a matter of fact, if the basic math facts do not become automatic, it could potentially hinder further growth in math. nutsandbolts It’s the same with phonics and sight words. We want readers to understand the nuts and bolts of decoding words (phonics). I would even propose that the reason we teach phonics by studying word features is to help words stick better into memory for reading AND spelling. But if we stop at phonics and do not help readers use that knowledge to move words into memory, I believe we are doing them a disservice; for if readers have to stop at many words in a text to sound them out or find patterns they know, growth in their reading could be greatly hindered, especially fluency and comprehension. They need to have words, especially the most common words, locked in memory. Automatic.

 Two Things to Keep in Mind:

  1. While we want to pull words out of context (away from actual reading) to study them, analyze them, and play with them, we want to be sure we are always bringing them back to REAL reading and REAL writing.
  2. Some kids need explicit and systematic phonics instruction (and still struggle to “get it”) while other kids seem to completely unlock the “code” of language by themselves (even as a 3 year old)! All kids are different and they all learn at their own pace.

Phonics or Sight Words - Teaching Kids to Read

 

More Resources:

Teaching Kids to Spell: A Developmental Approach to Spelling

  • My ebook, Teaching Kids to Spell: A Developmental Approach to Spelling, gives lots of hands-on and developmentally appropriate ideas for teaching kids to study words (both with phonics and sight words).
  • Phonics vs. Sight Words {from Stories and Children}
  • The Teaching of Sight Words {Part 1 and Part 2}
  • When Sight Words Just Don’t “Stick”
  • Helping Spellers Develop Phonics Generalizations
  • Teaching Spelling Through Word Study {10 day series}

Follow This Reading Mama’s board Sight Words on Pinterest.

Follow This Reading Mama’s board Word Study/Phonics on Pinterest. Follow This Reading Mama’s board Hands-On Spelling Ideas on Pinterest.

 

 

Enjoy!

~Becky

 

Want MORE Free Teaching Resources?

Join thousands of other subscribers to get hands-on activities and printables delivered right to your inbox!

Filed Under: Learn to Read, Phonics and Word Study, Reading Readiness, Sight Words Tagged With: Phonics, reading, Sight Words, teaching

« Finding Topics for Journal Writing
DIY Sticker Mats for Fine Motor Play »

Comments

  1. Cassie @ 3Dinosaurs.com says

    May 1, 2014 at 8:52 am

    I love this post! I had someone tell me they were only teaching phonics because their child did not need sight words. I think it is why I love BOB Books. They have phonics and some sight words to start off on. Both together slowly build up reading in a great way!

    Reply
    • thisreadingmama says

      May 1, 2014 at 3:01 pm

      The crazy thing is that words like cat and dog (totally phonics words, right?) become sight words once the child knows them by sight. So, by teaching phonics and being exposed to these words, they become sight words.

      Reply
  2. naumanea says

    May 1, 2014 at 9:01 am

    I was JUST having a conversation about this yesterday at our community playgroup. A mom told me she only teaches phonics because she read research that showed that a child’s “memory bank” fills up and gets overloaded when we try to teach too many sight words. I have a hard time believing that. Even as an adult, I think I’m adding new (longer) sight words to my “memory bank” as I read more and more. I’d love to hear if anyone else has seen research pertaining to this concept.

    Reply
    • thisreadingmama says

      May 1, 2014 at 2:58 pm

      The idea of the memory bank getting filled up makes sense if you are teaching your child sight words at a level that is not appropriate for the child, like I mention here–> https://thisreadingmama.com/2011/08/11/sight-words-when-they-just-dont-stick/ But we want reading to be fluent so that comprehension is at its finest. And getting those words, especially the most common ones, to stick in memory helps in this process. I really like Linnea Ehri’s work for reading research. The Reading Teacher (peer-reviewed journal) is also a great source.

      Reply
  3. Emma @ P is for Preschooler says

    May 2, 2014 at 12:57 am

    Wonderful post! My daughter is just getting to the point where I need to think about this. I like your idea of using both phonics and sight words – it just makes sense!

    Reply
    • thisreadingmama says

      May 2, 2014 at 5:39 am

      Yes, it does. I think we have to remember to keep literacy in balance. If we lean too far one way (phonics) or the other (sight words), our spelling and reading instruction can have holes in it and we want to build a SOLID foundation. 🙂

      Reply
  4. Meghan Hunt says

    May 2, 2014 at 5:29 am

    Have you checked out the new spelling program Spelling U See by the folks at math you see? My oldest son, now 10 has been struggling with reading and spelling for years. I have tried a lot of programs but am impressed with this one and plan to try it out in the fall. Would love to hear your review of it!

    Reply
    • thisreadingmama says

      May 2, 2014 at 5:37 am

      Hi Meghan. I don’t know much about Spelling U See. I have only used All About Spelling and Words Their Way. I love both of these because they address phonics and sight words in hands-on, developmentally appropriate ways. I’d be interested to hear what you think once you implement it. 🙂

      Reply
  5. dpageteach00 says

    September 13, 2014 at 10:36 am

    Great post! Thank you!! I teach special ed (Multiply disabled) and have a hard time teaching this. I have been using BOTH as well bc I have to, please keep sharing any ideas and tips you have!!!

    Reply
  6. Bridget says

    January 14, 2015 at 9:44 pm

    Those of you who are looking for a fabulous reading program, check out Logic of English. It is an incredible program! I was a phonic + sight words person too until I did a ton of research and began this program. I am not against sight words to aid phonics but I teach them a whole new way now. I have seen my six year old go from being a non-reader, to reading words like language and esophagus with ease. She can read books chock full of sight words easily but she can also decode most any word with basic phonograms or some advanced phonograms. Please check out this program! It is well worth your time. Your kids will thrive off of it.

    Reply
    • thisreadingmama says

      January 14, 2015 at 9:48 pm

      The Logic of English reminds me a bit of Words Their Way. I think kids need to understand that MOST words in the English language are predictable and follow certain “rules”. You just have to understand the logic of it. That’s why I often like to mix sight words and phonics together so kids can see the connection that most words share.

      Reply
  7. Chris Hennick says

    September 15, 2016 at 8:23 pm

    Why not use only those words that are exceptions to phonics (like “Christmas” and “should”) as sight words? Phonics works most of the time, so let it do its job wherever it can. If that’s not what most English speakers wanted, we’d be writing everything with ideographs like the Chinese do.

    Reply
  8. Jennifer Horta says

    December 9, 2020 at 11:21 am

    Thanks for this post. It was really helpful as I’m trying to teach my son how to read. We use All About Reading but I wasn’t sure what exactly a sight word was, this post explains it well.

    Reply

Trackbacks

  1. More free phonics books! (set 3) - The Measured Mom says:
    October 18, 2014 at 6:17 am

    […] I’m not going to take sides and declare one piece of the reading puzzle more important, because children need to know words by sight and have the ability to sound out unfamiliar ones.    This Reading Mama put it well in her article: Phonics or Sight Words? […]

    Reply
  2. Battling for Sight Word Treasures - Liz's Early Learning Spot says:
    October 30, 2014 at 12:47 am

    […] Sight Words: If you’re not sure about sight words skip over to This Reading Mama. I love this article she wrote talking about phonics and sight words. […]

    Reply
  3. Learning Phonics with Fall Leaves says:
    November 3, 2014 at 9:00 am

    […] no surprise that learning phonics is an essential part of learning to read. And when it comes to teaching phonics skills, I much prefer hands-on activities (and for the most […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

JOIN MY NEWSLETTER

and get free printables!

Sign me up!


Hi! I’m Becky, a homeschooling mama with 4 blessings who keep me on my toes {and knees}. Before homeschooling, I was a classroom teacher (M.Ed.) and reading tutor. Read more about me here.

Let’s Get Connected!

  • Email
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

  • Home
  • Start Here
  • Subscribe
  • Shop
  • Checkout
  • Privacy
  • Affiliates

Copyright © 2023 · Designed by Visibilia Media

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkRead more